1)Felipe_9595: This is a guy who KNOWS how to play as a townie. Sure he didn't make any revolutionary deductions, but he understood the basic concept of lynching. Vote,Pressure,ask for claim before lynching. Not to mention this mafia could have been completely one sided had he not used his night actions on night 2.

2)135: He was the one guy who kept on his toes, he never bought into others words and thought completely indepent. He also kept his priorities straight(protecting Dephius from night 2) and he did make some good deductions against Nixter. I sometimes think that everyone underestimates this guy sometimes. What puts him at number 2 you might say? Well...I WILL NEVER FORGIVE HIM FOR PRACTICALLY KILLING BRIK AFTER HE WAS CONFIRMED BY A UNCOUNTERED COP. Its one thing to think indepentently...its another to be hard headed.(I actually wanted to put him at number 3 for this, but his pros are pretty impressive.)

3)Sonicstormer38: I'll be honest, this guy was the best new player in the game. Sure he did banwagon on the first 2 lynches, but he quickly realized he had to think by himself and wait for actual evidence and not someone's words. He also realized the importance of a vigilante role and went straight for it. He made some pretty good deductions on PM too. The only thing that brought his score down was that he killed Flash and Flames on Night 4 which could have saved the town actually.

4)Prince Marth: This guy is subtle, and thats what a mafia should try to act like. He never jumped to accuse someone and always waited for someone to say something first. He even voted for his own mafia brother to stay in the crowd. Clearly out of all the mafia Prince marth was the best at blending in with the crowd, which is the most important parts of mafia. He did however have his few trips. Like him hammering Brik(which was VERY scum like) and aiming for dephius as a nightkill(even though the doctor would mostly likely be on him.)

5)DJ wizard cop: This guy was clearly the head of the mafia. He made all the plans, he did the evil laugh and he lynched 2 townies. He was also truly dedicated to his fake claim(even though no one was buying it) His arguments were way too aggressive though and his claim was flawed. If he had lasted alittle longer I may have found some justified reason to put him over Prince Marth.

6)Thomas Terminator: He was almost there, he was going to be the first REAL third party to make it. He stayed inactive for the most part, but who can blame him. However thats where the problem lies. He was TOO inactive. He should have tried to make sure that the game was dragged out as long as it could for more time to deliever presents, especially when people were dissapearing. Not to mention he ALWAYS helped the town for some reason. As soon as he figured out Dephius was the cop, he tried to deliever a present to him twice. This was also after a mafia was killed, instead of trying to help the town you should have tried the opposite for some more time.

7)Infinity: Once again someone who seemed fairly new. He lynched on the first 2 days,but realized it wasn't working so well. He made some pretty good arguments against DJ as well. The fact is though, he didn't know his partner on day one and should have been more cautious about who he voted for. Not to mention because his partner was lynched on day 1 he didn't have any night roles to speak of.

8)Mr. Flash and Flames: Now this guy is not so great. He bandwagonned for a good amount of time and he didn't keep his actions on Dephius like 135 did. I do give him props for debunking DJ's claim with the pokedex, but without it...

9)Pachino: I know, I know he really didn't get to do anything, but thats the only thing that puts him so low. He did investigate Brik which was a fairly smart move, but he had no time after that to do anything.

10)Crabby: He died quickly and didn't get a chance to develope any strategies. The only thing I consider bad about the way he played is how he tried to end the 1st day as fast as possible.

11)Brikmaninoff: Brik made some very fair deductions towards DJ wizard, but was killed immediately after so he couldn't act on them. He also didn't take into account that cactus is new to the game and took his error for a mafia vibe. To be honest though his kill directed towards Pachino ws actually alittle reasonable considering what happened last game.

12)Cactus: Here's another example where getting lynched early puts you in the middle of the list. The only reason he's under Pachino and Crabby is because he didn't have any night actions and made a bad move on day 1. Other then that though he didn't do anything.

13)Dephius: Yep. He got innocent results throughout the WHOLE game and didn't see anything fishy. He didn't think independently and instead relied on his role through the entire game. Also he should have known something was screwed up when thomas terminator turned out to be a third party instead of a townie like his investigation said.

14)Nixter: ...He did a horrible job at blending in with the town, he did not ask his teammates for a confirm on his role of the first night. In fact he said and I quote "So I should make 135 look like a deadbeat? On it." and his next post with non in between was "Done" Also the way he acted was way to out of character. I know he was trying to be the person he always was, but he clearly tried WAY too hard. If you look at the last mafia nixter was having laughs and making jokes. In this mafia he yelled like no tommorrow.