Now excuse me, how was it going to work with 135's role if he also was naïve?

He wasn't. Remember, he got a guilty on Lucina.

He was. His role description states him as such!



We already concluded the chances of a framer somewhere in the setup, because its the only thing explaining how 135 got a guilty.

So, according to Geno, we have two naïve investigators. Isn't that a bit fishy?

Whoops, forgot that, sorry. Anyway, I'm guessing Geno's role works with 135's role in that their results would match up; Geno gets a safe claim on a person while 135 gets an innocent to "confirm" the person's town status.

Also, Geno doesn't know himself if he's naive or not. No one does.

The mere fact that he got Axel's safe claim when investigated him confirms he is naïve (or at least, that his results are ambiguous enough to not matter). Also, Apple, you have just proven how this investigative combo is completely useless for the town: 135 and Geno investigate the same mafia player and they get not only an innocent, but they also confirm the safe claim, making the combo not only useless, but also incredibly dangerous for the town.

I'm pretty sure a framer can cause Geno to investigate a safe-claim. You can't just conclude that Geno's naive because he investigated a safe-claim. The mafia framer is not dead; we have two mafia members left after Axel was lynched, and Axel was not the framer, so we can conclude that the framer is still alive and may have tempered with Geno's investigation of Axel.

That theory would also makes sense because I announced that I would investigate Axel, easy pickings for the framer.

OK then. We know now than Geno's ability may be affected by framers too.

We have two options:
-We lynch and risk to lose the game, but get information.
-We no lynch and risk a happily ever after.

I think we have to lynch someone. If it has to be me, even, I'd be ok. We must take the risk somehow if we want to win this game.

Well, we should consider our options for lynching if we want to do one today. Since Pachino is a confirmed townie (right?):

194, myself, Brik, Apple Engi, Cactush

this is our lynch pool today.

I think if we have to go with one it should be Cactush, but that's just going off of raw gut instinct. I want those two dead townies and the third party to be revealed.

I would be fine with it if I had to be Lynched, my abilities aren't helping anyone much in my opinion.

I guess I'll agree to risk losing the game for information. For who to lynch, I'm leaning towards 194 or Cactus through gut instinct. Although, for who the better choice is, probably Cactus considering how with 194, we have a chance of ruining the mafia's kill.

Writing reasons for lynching:

-Brik: Claimed doctor. Hasn't died on the last two days. Very low activity.
-Apple: Not sure if he has claimed. Low information from his posts.
-Cactush: Claimed tracker. Low information from his ability, bad posting game overall
-Geno: Claimed flavor cop. Very low information received from his ability, agressive post game.
-194: Claimed one-way bus driver. Has constantly messed with Geno's ability, somewhat fishy post game the last few days.

My apologies for the inactivity, I've been swamped at school

I agree we have to take the risk and lynch someone or else we won't get anything done.

My gut instinct is a Cactus/Brik scum team. Cactus because he hasn't given a whole lot of information off of his ability (why would he even investigate me when I'm a confirmed townie anyways?), and Brik because doctor not dying seems a little off to me although it could be the mafia playing tricks on us

i'll be the first then

Vote: Cactus