And I'm sure you haven't.

I'd like to know the real reason you said that.

Allright, reread through and found some stuff.

Thomas' play here is how I remember it in 14. Lurking, little content, and RL excuses. No offense.

Krillin is at least posting more, but there's no content in his posts at all other than random accusations and obvious remarks. Nothing new, nothing original, just blatant sheeping.
What makes him different from Axel in 14 is that I see no effort to make the game progress. At least Axel tried to help, even in a weird way(sheeping me). I don't see that here.
Active Lurking is a tactic employed by scum often, and if you don't look for it, scum get away with it easily.

@F&F, Thomas, JC: We need more content.

On a side note, JC has suddenly become reeeeeeaaaaaly apathetic towards mafia in general.

Krillin seems to be a genuinely scummy village idiot, I wouldn't mind passing the bomb to him if it came to me. Actually, that brings a good question to mind, if you received the bomb, who would you pass it too?

I've already passed it to the person I would pass it to.

Before I forget:

Pass: Krillin III

Right now, I would pass it to Krillin, too.

Starting to not like Terra’s posts.
Just because you’re Mr. Mafia Meta doesn’t mean you can go after inexperienced targets like that.
You’re relying too much on meta and mafia theory. I have yet to see a proper analysis of one of your FoS’s posts.

Honestly though Arthur, I’m not going to let you get away with such an obvious bandwagon jump.
Explain your reasons for voting Krillin a bit better.

Requesting force replacements on Krillin, Flash & Flame and Thomas.

I’m going to have to agree with TOWK here and say we should vote explode to -1.
Once we agree on a target, we pass it to someone who hasn’t voted explode yet, then that person passes it to our target and votes explode.
(Pass before you vote. We don’t want you detonating it on yourself)
If our target decides to speed lynch, they’re an obvious lynch for tomorrow.

Mostly that he hasn't been posting much, and when he does post, it isn't helpful.

Fair enough.

Vote: explode

Sorry about that. I'm just not too sure of what we should do. We have this bomb which is going to go off on somebody and we don't really have a big lead. I've just been watching to see if anybody slips up.

I'm not relying on meta so much as trying to analyze the difference between newbtown and newbscum, becasue I really don't want newbscum to get away with the "I'm new" card.



I have to agree with this. There's no logical reason not to.
Vote: Explode

And also, I'd like to take the opportunity to update my reads, but for the most part they remain the same.

Krillin jumps further ahead to become my top suspect for the following reason:
Overarching intent to just get through the day.
He hasn't posted any content apart from a few basic comments on things. I wanna take a look at his mindset here a little more: does he really believe this is good scumhunting(even in a twisted way) or is he not trying to scumhunt at all?
I believe the latter. If he was like Shoop and playing only for one, well, he'd be much less serious. However, his shades of seriousness in some posts plus the lack of general content make me worried as to his alignment. I don't see any possible partners for him, which makes me somewhat less suspicious.

Looking at Krillin's interactions with others, he responds to Kyuubit in a very light-hearted manner, as if he doesn't take the game seriously or to shake pressure off himself. I think in this case it's the former, so I'm starting to doubt myself on this read.
~~~~
If DJ wasn't already my top townread, he's my top townread now. Of everyone I've seen, I think his posts are good for the following(two) reasons:
1)Overarching intent to help the town.


This post states what he thinks of the game very clearly, and he's not afraid to suspect the more experienced players like myself, 194 and TOWK. This covers a lot of the situation, and is a good analysis while not derailing the town.
I've seen mafia counterwagon with a good post before, but definitely not in this manner. From the post, it doesn't make sense that, if he were mafia, he would try to derail the town by suspecting 194.

It's not just this post: a lot of his other posts contain this type of stuff too.

2)Interactions with others
From what I've seen, he's not afraid to confront other people and change his reads often, which in my opinion is far more likely to come from town than scum. From his interactions with prominent figures(TOWK and 194) it's safe to say that his arguing looks to be scumhunting-driven, rather than arguing for the sake for arguing. For now I can't make conclusiong on TOWK and 194 just yet on this alone, but I'm pretty certain DJ is town.

#RANT