I don't think you realise that by pushing this hard for one specific person since the beginning makes you appear highly suspicious.

Nahhhh. It's already practically confirmed that either A: JiP is paranoid. B: JiP is insane. C: JiP is mafia. All of these but C prevent Tid from being mafia, and I'm not gonna go around throwing votes on him just yet. I'd rather go for someone else. In fact, I specifically avoided it.

You seem awfully certain you've caught me, acting as if your little hunch is deadset proof to everyone that I'm a mafia.
I think you should definitely care if you look scumsided, as doing so is going to make people want to lynch you. If you're a townie, then getting lynched would definitely disadvantage us, especially seeing as we're already losing up to two of us per night. So why don't you care?

I didn't get a guilty on a thrid party role. Shin used the lie detector, and he wasn't a pirate, nor was he a third party member:


That's nice. Kill the newbie.
Nah, I'm going for whoever slips in their dialogue between Tid and SnowFlakeCat.

I'm most likely one of the two.

Right now, you really feel like lynching Tid. You don't even try to reconsider or have another suspect.
Forcing others to lynch Tid is going to make people lose trust in you. You might even be a pirate, trying to lynch an innocent person.

This is exactly why I shouldn't be accused. Why I am so knowledgable? Because I'm the only one here actually analysing what everyone is saying and looking at who died, and pulling clues from the tiny hints we're getting here and there.

@Tid: I'm pretty sure the killing role is dead, and I will explain to you why.



I don't have an investigative role, but I'm scouring everyone's posts for information. You guys shouldn't be accusing me, you should be thanking me.


I was backing up Tid at the beggining because he was being helpful and trustworthy. As a townie, I believe it is my responsibility to defend those I believe the be innocent.
Now... I'm not so sure. Between Tid and Nooq, I have a strong feeling that one of them is Mafia. I'll wait to see how this plays out before voting.

Well, I guess since you are so willing to lynch Tid, I won't suspect you for a while today.
I think you should say your role. I mean, right now, I'm thinking Tid's right and that the third-party killer was killed.
Just a suggestion. There's no regular crew member on the ship (seriously, use the space terms).

Nook, you have no backing. You keep coming back to the point that JiP may in fact be sane because he got a guilty on a third party member, and now your FoS.
But it's as JiP says, that's not the case. Shin wasn't a third party member, he was a completely innocent investigative role.
I feel like this is the hundredth time I've said this, but there is no question. JiP is NOT a normal cop. While there's the possibility that he's paranoid, it's also likely that he's insane, which would confirm that I'm innocent. Even if he's Mafia, he wouldn't be calling out one of his own as guilty, which is more reason to see me as townsided. Whatever he turns out to be, there's definitely no conclusive proof from your point of view, unless you have some sort of revealing role you aren't telling us about. (Once again I'd like to point out that you still haven't told us how you were so certain Shin wasn't a miller)
This is pretty typical mafia activity. You're turning the tiniest things into scumtell and following it through to appear townsided. You could just as easily have chosen War Panda's inactivity, or [:]'s uncanny knowledge of the mafia. But you didn't, you chose me and my stupid mistake of not fully reading the, very long-winded mind you, rule description at the start of this topic, which just happens to be a much less suspicious action than both of the alternatives I detailed above.

Now you're the one misreading things. I said that even if they did have a poisoner (Which we have absolutely no way of knowing), they didn't use it since two people died on night one. (Which is a confirmed fact.)

My knowledge of the Mafia isn't uncanny by any stretch of the imagination. I picked up a valuable clue from Brik's mistake, and now you guys are accusing me for helping.

You noted it, and asked him about it, but really when you could be voting someone that has this implied knowledge for no explained reason, you're lynching me for something stupid, a mistake anyone could've made. I read the rules, but they changed a lot, and had a whole bunch of gimmicks at the start. Excuse me if I skimmed some bits.
Nothing you say or do is going to change how scummy it is for you to ignore other issues and focus on this one tiny thing, pushing for an unbacked lynch like this.

That explains a LOT of things.

It would explain a lot if someone had gotten a guilty on him. It's like he's using this role now so that when he gets investigated and shown up as guilty, he'll have an excuse.
He's just preparing in advance. At first I thought he might've been a crew member who was just FoSing me, but the way he's acting towards me when I know that I'm townie... From my point of view, you have to understand why I think he's mafia.
Vote: Nooq

*Tries to Stay Calm*

I said that if even if they had a poisoner, they didn't use it on night one because two people died.
Why would I suspect they had a poisoner in the first place? Because two people died tonight as well.
Why is this a problem? Because there was an "error in the system".
So inherently, this tells us two things. One, the killing role is dead, and two, the Mafia have a special role of some sort.

See, it's not uncanny at all. It's just pure logic.

It does seem odd that of all the conclusions we could draw from two deaths N1, you chose the oddly specific and out of the way "If they happened to have a poisoner they didn't use it.".

Ugh. That was the best way I could think of saying it. I have no idea if they have a poisoner! How should I?
I just... oh, nevermind. I've said it a bajillion times now, if you still don't believe me, then I don't know what to say.