Why on earth would we agree to go with whatever Toad gave us if he's pretty much confirmed to not be an accurate investigator? He got a Guilty on our only clear.

You don't even consider the fact that you might be a pirate.

I'm speaking from my point of view. Obviously I know that I'm not a pirate, so I'm not even going to consider that when I'm theorising.

IDK what to do now. MAny people, many possible FoS... The only thing I know is: we have to Lynch someone today.
Give me suspicious people and I'll decide.

I don't want to lynch random people.

Okay good. The less inactive people the better.

Can we please make a new rule that for the duration of this game, you can't change your name, avatar, or make major changes to your signature? Kthxbai.

Anywho, you could investigate me, unknown194, snowflakecat, etc. Really any of the active guys.
But we need to lynch someone now. Our primary suspect is Tid. We decided yesterday (Mafia time, of course) that we would be going with anything Toad's investigation brought us.
Because of this being a no-role reveal set up, we're having a significant lack of leads. Tid is the only one we have at the moment. I say we go with it and hope for the best.

Vote: Tid

Alright, s#%$&'s getting serious. Time to start posting my thoughts.
[:]
Why? He agreed with me on my no-lynch idea, with one little difference. He KNEW it was a role-reveal setup. However, he later started acting quite pro-town and I'm beginning to think that maybe it was just a tactical error on his part. Then suddenly he popped up as suspicious again when he said "we would be going with anything Toad's investigation brought us.", when Toad was confirmed to be either paranoid/insane or just lying about who he is. Maybe mafia. I'm hesitant to lynch him at this point, but he's definitely someone I'm going to be watching a little more closely.

War Panda and Bandanna Dee
War Panda sticks out to me. He's hardly posted except for at the very start, and yesterday he magically started talking just after I mentioned how inactive he was being. Tad suspicious if you ask me. Bandanna Dee has the same problem, only he's just not talking full stop, which leads me to believe that he's probably just inactive. My FoS is War Panda, definitely.

The investigative roles
Obviously Shin was one of the investigative roles. He's definitely town sided so we have reason to believe what he tells us. In another game, I'd suspect maybe he was just a regular townie acting as a decoy so that the real investigator can do their thing, but apparently there are no regular townies in this game, so he's very likely to be who he says. The other one at this point is probably Toad (JiP), but if he is, he's confirmed to be paranoid or insane. He could easily be a mafia though, and constantly getting guilties is kind of suspicious. But if he isn't sane, his story checks out.
One last piece thought on Toad (JiP) is that even after getting a guilty on our only clear, he continued to "consider" the possibility of not being paranoid or insane. I feel like if he was who he says he is, he'd instantly know for sure of his... Less than sane state. The third investigative role seems to be keeping quiet, so maybe he's mafia? I would like however to point out that earlier on, nook said that he had his reasons as to why Shin wasn't a miller. So unless he's lying, he's probably another sort of role-revealing role. Unless of course he collected an item that lets him find out people's roles?

My FoS is definitely War Panda at this point though.

IDK what to do now. MAny people, many possible FoS... The only thing I know is: we have to Lynch someone today.
Give me suspicious people and I'll decide.

You post, and you're already gone. I think this is my FOS.