Ok, well, that's 3 supposedly town and 1 conf town that suspect SS. Is everyone willing to vote yet? I know we should wait for SS to respond, and I'd like some words from terra, but I just want to know where we stand here.

I'd like to hear from both of them before I make up my mind.

I know you're Town-sided, but I still have rather different opinions from yours.

Activity-level, while generally a nice way to base suspicion off of, shouldn't IMO be such a large factor. Can a person be inactive, but still Town-sided? Yes. Can the contrapositive be true? I think so. That being said, I myself find most of the players to be somewhat suspicious (except for you and myself lol). SOme more than others, but there's not really anyone I would label as "probably Town-sided".

Well, Lucina seems to be pretty Town-Sided, but that was what I thought last time when she was Mafia, so :/
IDK D:

I did chang it just once and it was the first time in years D:

So what ARE your reads, 135? And why specifically pick Lucina out of the group?

Right now my prime suspects are 194, Terra, and, sorry, to say, yourself. I specifically picked out her because I thought she was one of the least suspicious players to me.

194 - Still in the game, limited active puzzle-solving activity. I'd expect him to be a bit more proactive if he were town, instead of mostly following you around(HMM).

Terra - for reasons stated by other players. I'm not too sure, though.

You - Suggested a Role-Claim, which might have been intentional or not. Generally very active during the game, although that doesn't make me less suspicious. Was one of the supporters of Nixter's lynch. Again, seems to have a slight bit of "coordination" with 194.

The role claim was an honest mistake. I had hardly thought of it at all before suggesting it. I for whatever reason figured PR's would claim and the rest would claim VT. And I don't see this "coordination" with 194. We don't agree on a good many things, the role claim being one of them.

194, to answer your question, I’ll be posting my reads over here, as well as quoting my reason why I started pushing so hard for a Nixter lynch.

Quote:
I really don’t want the town to end in an NL today, sonicstormer, as at least alycnh will leave something for us to work with.

Reads:
194-Neutral/Scum.-From the way you’ll been attacking, that’s been highly townish. However, you’ve defended Nixter until the end, and he ended up town. You may have known that, and ended up trying to defend him, for townie points?
TOWK-Neutral/Scum.-Many of these reasons have been mentioned before, including the massclaim, and the relentless attacks on Nixter.
Deph-Conf. Town.- Nothing more to say here.
135-Neutral/Town.- Gives me a townish vibe. Defended Nixter a lot during Day 2, but doesn’t really look the same way as 194.
Sonicstormer-Neutral/Scum.- Been lurking a lot lately, and posts just enough to avoid being kicked from the game. Has been bringing up good points, however.
Lucina-Neutral. Can’t say for sure.

Will expand when I get home.

-I've already explained the massclaim thing, and my "relentless attacks" on Nix originally started as a way to pressure and add more conversation. I feel my attacks were completely warranted once I analysed his previous games and his "I have no reads" thing. Sure, the actual lynch itself was probably a little rushed, but Deph did quickhammer him.
-your reasons for attacking 194 seem like complete BS to me. You say he's been playing highly townish, defended Nixter, then say he's scum? Where did you get that from? It seems like you may just be going along with whatever 135 says.

Still waiting on Sonicstormer to post anything...

@TheOneWhoKnocks
Happy birthday!

I saw him on the forums earlier, not sure if he looked at the game. Don't know why he wouldn't though.

And thank you!

Why is 135 just Null/Town and not straight Town? He really looks townis to me, no matter of his opinions about me. Also, why is SS only Null/Scum? I'd call his lurking work straight scum. Also, what is the exact difference between me and 135 in regards to Nixter's defense? I can acknowledge I ended up voting Nix once he told that he had no reads (and therefore, proved himself non-cooperative, giving me an obvious scumvibe). 135 held his opinion beyond that point, why doesn't that make him more suspicious than me? I have no way to know Nix was town before his death, therefore, I could endup changing my opinion; but there's a chance 135 knew Nix was town after all, and then decided to keep his defense even when he had lost all credibility for the rest of the players.

135, what do you think of Terra?

Why is everyone withholding their votes on SS?

He still hasn't said anything yet.

Should we make a deadline for a reply?