I don't personally see anything wrong with nixter either. I pointed out that he acted over defensive, and I figured if I pressured him which a vote and he overreacted again, it would mean he was scum. He reacted well though, so my suspicion is off of him for now. unvote:nixter

Look harder.

Let's look at what how Tid was killed.

-He was active
-He openly protested, and with good points, which could be a factor in his death.
-Mafia may have though eye for an eye was benficial to them, and Tid was protesting hard.

If you guys come up with something else please share it.

beneficial*
thought*

Sorry

So what exactly are you getting out.

135, I don't get why are you having so much trouble figuring this. As proven by Mg Mafia 10, Tid is a very valuable player in the long run. Probably, Mafia decided to take the "the sooner we kill him, the better" way and took him out, especially considering that, after all that discussion and disagreeing with other players, he wouldn't be protected by a JK (if there's one).

I'm perfectly aware of the reasons Tid was most likely killed. To me it seems he was killed just because he was a good player. But why does that point to Nixter being the Mafia? There's nothing rally wrong with him except for maybe an over use of "yo". And btw, Nixter was the one who brought up the eye for an eye thing if I remember correctly, and tid agreed with him. I don't think the Mafia would kill off a good player who agreed with one of their members' ideas.

I was infact the one who brought up the eye for an eye.

I was talking about his personality, I haven't said anything relating Nixter to scum yet.


I don't think Tid was agreeing at all.

My mistake. I didn't actually read back, because I'm posting from my phone and going from page to page and posting is a pain in the a**. I had just remembered BB saying it was a bad idea and Tid was arguing with him.
When I said "nothing wrong" with nixter, I was referring to scummy things. Yes, his personality in his postings could use some work, but he still seems null/town to me.

I'm going to assume null means neutral.

It means haven't determined whether you're scum or town, so yes essentially neutral.

I had that in mind as well as my primary theory. I was just looking for responses to see what other people would think, since responses would be helpful. I originally thought that you were a likely Mafia candidate because you know how well Tid plays (Skype games lol), and might possibly consider him such a threat that you'd rather get rid of him yourself than have the town get rid of him (a lot of people were disagreeing with him, so perhaps some might think that he was trying to feed us with false assumptions).

But your response seems...rather...non-suspicious. I suppose I suspect you a bit less now. I might still come back and analyze this post further, though.

Where's BelieveBlood? He hasn't posted yet Day 2. I'd like his input on what's going on.

Yes I don't like the way Nixter is acting. Wether this is a result of just playing bad or actually being a mafia is beyond me.
He was first inactive and was then investigated by Tid because of it, but that was shortly stopped.
Then he constantly insist that the eye for an eye tactic was good even though people kept telling him that it wasn't, the only ones who backed him up were Dephius(temporarily) and Tid(not completely).
He then votes for a no lynch(personally anyone who banwagoned on that looks scummy.).
When day two rolls around Tid dies and Nixter almost immediately implies it was because me and him were arguing, even though there were four other people who would also look scummy in the process
He also insist that the mafia would want to do that as an expected twist similiar to how the eye for an eye tactic he implied.
When he gets accused of something he gets defensive and tries to redirect the problem to something else(Sonicstormer)
If you put all these together you can't help but feel a little suspicious of him, but he hasn't had such a good track record so I really don't know if this is the result of bad play or not.

I see. Do you have any other suspicions? Also, I haven't read you about the Nixter issue. Any thoughts?