Back with the third Kirby Ability tier list. There is hierarchy within each tier.

Sorry about the long wait, I've been somewhat busy and though this discussion has pretty much died down I've polished my last two lists a little more. Feel free to criticize it should you have any objections to placements.

Luffy is S tier. Kirby can use in the air to later fence of pains oponents, also can tether recovery and start combos.
Black Mage is C tier because is not useful at all, only stops oponents.
G&W is E tier, just spam sausages without any use.

Black Mage's ability gives Kirby free combos and edgeguards. Game & Watch can be useful for edgeguarding. and luffy's doesn't provide the versatility of Pac's and Falco's.

While of course i'm gonna point out that Stop (Black Mage ability) does reflect projectiles, i think it would still be too laggy for Kirby's playstyle, especially how for some reason he goes "castlevania mode" and can't control his air movement (aside from fast-falling) during the move, which would definitely make spacing much harder to really get to do much with this ability aside from a rather risky punish option

It still let's Kirby get combos on black mage and get Black Mage offstage which will lead to an easy kill.

This is my first tier list and it's my opinion so please respect it.

Explain why Tails is worst character?

He isn't. if were to actually put him on the list he would be a b. but the reason he's below everyone is because i really want the dev team to bring back v0.9b tails.

Peach being the worst and Game and Watch being top 3 just isn't even remotely correct.

Peach being top 3 and Game and Watch being the worst though, well, that's more reasonable. I do respect your opinion, but there's a LOT of things wrong with this.

sure, also pichu in high, bdee in high, there are so many things that you gotta fix.

I think i'll be good on that one. i have my own opinion and i'm not changing it.

Ideally a tier list should have as little opinion as possible, no?

i guess it just depends on what it is. but tbh i'm looking at this again and yea i think some changes need to be made.

There is no way that Ichigo is D Tier.

Alright, new character interpretations.
Rayman is probably high or top tier. Amazing disjoints, good command grabs, good recovery, best Dair in the game, a lot of good stuff here.
Lucario and Waa are probably high tier. Lucario has a good combo game, an amazing projectile that is WAY too fast, and his Aura is nuts. Waa has a weak recovery, but in return INSANE edgeguarding and setups.
Krystal is low high tier, mainly because she has INSANE movement with platform and amazing edgeguarding and aerials... but the worst recovery in the game.
Simon is mid tier. Strong, but WAY too slow, and his projectiles don't make up for it.
Ryu I feel is low mid tier. He's too slow and True Shoryu has a VERY tight window, and he has a pretty bad recovery. He also just doesn't have good disjoints and range, with his mediocre projectile being good but just not good enough. IMO worst of the new characters.