I'm actually really tempted to just join the bandwagon. I mean, we haven't really gotten much to work with by having only one lead (which we aren't even sure might be true). Unless we can get some reads from Brik and Pachino or a claim from Lucina, I'll join the bandwagon because I don't want to no lynch again.

But what is Lucina is town?

Then we get info and reads out of it.

Will post more tomorrow. I'm on my phone right now and it's a pain to type on it.

Don't blindly jump into voting on someone, it never leads to good things, and it makes you look like you're panicking. If anything, this looks like a mafia move to try and save a fellow mafia (Lucina, as an example, I still believe he is town). Don't be so rash, Shoop has a point.

I just don't think she is scum.

Just because you don't think someone is scum it doesn't makes them town.

Uh. Guys, sorry, but I dont really get why people aren't voting.


Is it because you don't think my ability is functional? May I ask, why? No one has really given a decent reason why my role would be unreliable. And while it could be, assuming a Cop's ability is dysfunctional on the get-go without solid reasoning is rather unreasonable.


Is it because you think there is a Framer? Yes, that is possible, assuming that framers appear in 33% of games and there are 10 non-Mafia players, the chance of someone being target by a Framer is 3.3%. That is a rather insignificant probability. I do not see why it should be a major point of contention.


Is it because you guys are getting Town reads on Lucina? I might be a bit biased here, but having played with her with the past and knowing a bit about how she plays, I don't quite see why she would be giving off Town reads to anyone. She is one of my top suspects, with or without Night Action results. Since the beginning of Day 1, she has be "active", yet has barely posted any actual content. Her posts barely offer anything to help the Town, and also barely offers anything that could give us reads. This was similar to how she played as Mafia in one past game (I don't remember which one off the top of my head): Staying in the background, playing safe, averting strong statements, averting attention. I could understand a Null read on her, but Town? May I ask why?


Or, is it because you're Mafia?

It's because nothing is certain. If you really expected everyone to jump straight to a bandwagon because of your big reveal you're delusional.

"Nothing is certain" isn't really saying much lol
I mean, I'll agree with you if you say the Lynch isn't 100% safe (it's probably 90% safe, though), but again, we haven't got much time. Our options are quite simple, Lynch or no Lynch. Refraining from voting for the sake of pressuring and for the sake of Lynching nudges us towards the latter. Things aren't going to become clearer or more certain by our sitting around idle.

You still haven't explained why you think my ability is unreliable, BTW.

What does 90% safe even mean? Where are you pulling that figure from? There are no percentages in mafia, it's ignorant to think anything is x percent safe or unsafe, there is only uncertainty and risk taking. Since when are you so pro-lynch? No, the options are not that simple, quit making it look so easy.

I'm wondering if it's worth risking a mislynch. We could wait it out another day, have people use abilities (i could use mine on lucina for example to provide another point of view, figure out your cop alignment for sure that way).

135, things also won't become clearer by lynching, sorry to say. We may get some pointers out of it but lynching someone and saying "well if they flip town we learned valuable info anyway" isn't the way we should be going about this.

And um, what exactly is there for me to explain? It's not at all out of the realm of possibility that your cop ability could be paranoid or insane considering how many investigative type characters there are in breaking bad. It's also not out of the realm of possibility that King Arthur was actually who you're claiming to be, but someone on the mafia side used their ability to retain his information, allowing you to make a safe claim no town can counter. This is all conjecture, but they're all just as likely as the situation you're feeding us unfortunately.

That's why we shouldn't bandwagon on Lucina. We need to use this last day to consider every angle. Rushed, last second lynches like this are always for the worst.

Sorry for my inactivity guys,

Apple Engi:
Pretty active and really tries to get the game going, looks like he really is scum hunting, he looks town to me.
UltimateZendayaFan:
does things too often without a normal explanation. Hmm, pretty much 0 for the remainder.

Also, i haven't watched breaking bad, i'm doing some research now.

i'll be more active from now on, i'm reading the last 20 pages again now, and i''l give some more reads

I agree with Geno.

No lynch is probably the best option. I mean, sure we can get reads off of lynching Lucina but it's not really worth the risk.

Can't 135 just investigate himself after this?

If he's actual scum, then it won't matter. And if he's town, I'd rather have him doing useful investigations.