Lucina now, Deph next. Reads last.
Day 1-Random votes Cactus. Asks 194 about inactivity. Comments on my pressure vote on Crabby, saying that "some people aren't on all the time". Then asks TOWK whether he honestly believes that anyone would be pressured by one vote when it takes seven to lynch? Starts talking about the role list from Mg Mafia 7. Posts Mg Mafia 7 role list. Is not surprised at Brik's voting of me. Then something useless about how the mafs will not see it coming. More useless stuff, nothing generally contributing, making a few jokes. Then casts suspicion on TOWK and Brik, attracting a lot of attention in the process. Then says something about how people can play good scum with no experience. Then says DJ doesn't look scummy at all, agreeing with the town with little reasoning. Tells Crabby about my pressure vote again.
Day 2-Immediately is shocked over why Cactus died. Is a little confused over why they would go for him over confused players even after Brik's explanation. Mentions that Gastly is maf sided at that the message I received is not in the right format. Questions why I needed to say I was a cop(wasn't paying attention). Then states that the plot thickens. Mentions how Deph could be a maf roleblocker. Then starts attacking Deph for claiming doc so early. Some more stuff on Mafia 7, and even more stuff on Mafia 7 in the next two posts. Then assumes that no one else visited 135. Says that scumhunting isn't his strong suit. Nothing useful in a few more pages.

And that's it. Close to nothing contributed. I think this should be enough justification as to:
Vote:Lucina
@TOWK: Does this suffice as to why Brik voted for Lucina? Luke and Jenka were in Mafia 4 and Mafia 9 respectively, btw.

Well, no not really. All you're saying is that he hasn't contributed much, when some people have done things genuinely summy. I guess it's possible that he's trying to lay low, but I don't think it's justification to vote him. I'll vote him later Today or tomorrow if it'll get us a flip, but for now my vote stays.
Also my bad, for whatever reason I'm constańly getting Layton and cave story games mixed up, put together, etc.

I'm getting some serious scum reads from the last few posts . . . everything seems a bit rushed.

I'm suspiscious on how BB manages to pretty much vanish (one post in the last 3 pages, IIRC) as we get closer to a lynch. Other people too.

I'm personally getting more and more convinced that once we lynch Lucina he's going to flip scum and we can lynch TWOK.

TWOK has some pretty dumb reasoning: "194 wouldn't include two protective roles from the same game therefore Deph is scum"

First of all 194 designed both of those games and second of all, if they both came from the same game, why couldn't they both be in this one?

Of course they're not both from the same game but it seems like rather forced reasoning to lynch Deph. And maybe keep pressure off Lucina in the process.

My my main reason for voting Deph it's the fact that I think it's unlikely there's would be two protective roles from te same game, it's that after only two on him and light pressure, he claimed doctor when that was completely unnecessary. He could have been vague like Terra, but he got defensive and went straight for the claim.

What? My post was the first one on the previous page.

Disregard what I said I completely read that wrong.

Terra, my thanks to you for verbalizing what I was too lazy to.

Vote Count please.

I lost track.

The town looks like it's split in two(again).
To be honest I don't really know who side I should take.
Like I stated earlier in the game the chances of Dephius actually being the doctor is not that likely especially considering Terra's claim and Dephius actions before, but if we're wrong then we really screw up and we'll probably lose two protection roles.
On the other hand Lucina really hasn't contributed that much, his previous post are weird to say the least, and lynching him has less risk then lynching Dephius.

...I might have to read over the topic or something to make my final decision.

Game status

Voting Lucina: Brikmaninoff, DJ Wizard Cop, Terra
Voting Dephius: TheOneWhoKnocks, Crabby
Not voting: 135, Lucina, Void, Fly or Die, Dephius, Believeblood

Deadline: October 21st, 22:00 hrs.
With 11 players alive, 6 votes are required to cast a lynch.
If deadline is reached with no consensus, no lynch will happen.

So we can't reach consensus apparently. Should we No Lynch or just do it?
Since there are probably 3 to 4 Mafia, I think we are somewhat safe, but I suppose it really depends on 3rd party roles.

Let's heat it up a bit, shall we?
Vote: Lucina
Also please don't Hammer until we AT LAST have a Role-Claim lol

-AT LEAST-

Lucina lynch is bogus.

Dephius lynch makes more sense for the day, and if you want to play it a bit more save Believeblood lynch makes more sense than Lucina because of the reasons I stated earlier.

I'm keeping my vote on Deph. I want my scumhunter bonus.

So I've read the topic again along with other mafia games to see if Lucina acted the same way as he is now, the same goes for Dephius.
Specifically I looked back at mafia 7(where Lucina was townie), mafia 8 (where Dephius was force to claim on the second day and Lucina was a mafia.) and mafia 11.(just for more sources.)

Next


After all of these re reads and deductions I've finally made up my mind. Vote:Dephius
In fact, can I concrete vote or was that taken out because I really don't want to have second thoughts again.