Actually yes, scum would lynch inactive players because they are an easy target.
FoS: Terra

If scum continue to lynch inactive players and they all turn out to be town, the scum will become rather obvious.
The MG Mafia meta is evolving. We're much more likely to force replace inactive people than lynch them.

Pseudovote: 194

Pass: Lucina hasn't had a turn yet.

And when did I say they would continue doing so? Smart Mafia wouldn't. However, as proven by this community itself, it is fairly easy to get a free lynch in Day 1. You are taking my argument and extrapolating it too far.

Thanks, but no thanks.

Pass: King Arthur

I have a feeling that he's our best bet for a bomblynch today.

Pass: Terra

Why should we lynch inactive players? You're as bad as [:] passing the bomb to F&F.

@194: Your post was not an argument, it was a 1 sentence comment on someone else's post, which the majority of your posts consist of.
My point is that this community is getting better. There hasn't been Day 1 mislynch since MG Mafia 8 much less a Day 1 mislynch because of inactivity.
I am not extrapolating your post, I'm saying it doesn't really make sense at this point in MG Mafia's meta.
Please answer my question about which bigger fish we have to fry.

Current reads would be:

Scum: 194, TOWK, Arthur

Possibly Scum: Blood, Dephius, Krillin, Shoop, JC, Terra

Null: Everyone else

Probably town: Lucina, Terra, Shoop, JC

Requesting more content from Krillin, Densetsu, Thomas Terminator, King Kyuubit, James Clyde and Flash & Flame, and more body to the posts of 194 and Blood.

That wasn't dumb or a bad play. That was an uber prod, and I knew it was safe because I know this moderator too well. (He extended the fuse by 24 hours, eh?)

That said, my uber prod didn't work too well. But really I'd rather lynch 194 than Arthur.

Apologies for TP but man I just gotta talk. Please ignore the second to last sentence. My uber prod worked, just not for very long.

We got what, two posts out of F&F?

I refuse to believe you knew he would extend it. Sounds like an excuse to me.

Just so everyone knows I will be on a long road trip with no Internet for most of tomorrow, so don't expect posts from me.

My current reads on everyone combined with random blind intuition are leading me to believe that the Mafia are some combination of Shoop, JC, Arthur, 194, Dephius, [:], and TOWK, with a remaining person being the third party. But my random blind intuition isn't usually right.

Speaking of third party, does anyone have any ideas as to what kind of role the third party might be?

Given the nature of the setup, I'm thinking a serial killer or maybe a survivor. It would be hard to create another kind of role, and Brik isn't the kind of guy which would rely on fools or cultists. So yes, serial killer is the best bet imo, even more if we consider we haven't got that particular role in a while.

@194: And you're forgetting that lurking is inherently anti-town.
Getting rid of lurkers is not only something mafia would do: town want to get rid of them, since they're useless. If they don't replace out, then lynch them. Better for us to get rid of them now than have to deal with them come endgame, where the mafia would purposely leave them alive to be a hindrance to the town.

@DJ: I appear twice in your list.

Really man? Do you know exactly how the mafia win? By getting rid of townies, the number of townies have to stay above the mafia or the town loses. Why exactly do we as townies want to waste a lynch just to kill someone who is inactive? It does nothing but help the mafia. It would be a different story if say the townie was just plain bad and mislead the town through random babble, but inactive players do not.

I didn't know he'd extend it, but I knew he wouldn't let us off an inactive player one way or another.
I correctly guessed that he made Genis insane and not paranoid in MG Mafia 3, so my record so far is pretty good~

Can we please bomb 194? He's dodged my question for quite some time now.

@Terra: I'm not sure I completely agree with your first paragraph, but I put you in twice on purpose. Possibly scum but probably town.

Haven't been posting because I haven't had anything worthwhile to say (and posting just to look active always sounded stupid to me)

Will post reads tomorrow because 2 am isn't exactly the best time for thinking