S TIER:


BETWEEN S AND A TIER:


A TIER:


B+ TIER:


B- TIER:


C TIER:


my first tier list, so criticism is fine. discuss about it.

In my opinion, Peach is too high, mind explaining why she's there?

bbm and goku too low
jiggs and peach too high
blah blah blah
opinions

For this, you could put "A+ TIER" if you want to

Why is Lloyd so low and Sheik so high?

I think that the difference between Zelda and Sheik is too big. I agree that Sheik is a strong character with needles, f-air. combo game and whatnot, but S tier seems too high for her. Fox and Pikachu seem like stronger characters than her overall.

I also feel that Zelda is being underrated with Lighting Kicks the way they are along with B-throw being insanely strong and having really good utility moves with Din's Fire, Naryu's Love and Farore's Wind. Her matchups against swordies aren't too great since they do the whole excelling at mid-range thing better, but Sheik covers pretty much all of those matchups except for maybe Meta Knight, making Transform a boon for both characters. I think Zelda should be moved to bottom of A tier or something, though being below Black Mage or Goku would work.

I don't have much of an issue with Yoshi's placement, but I think B tier makes better sense for him since his overall lack of kill setups and kill power can get to him if he isn't getting offstage f-airs and his ground mobility and poor grab can hinder him at times. Eggs and f-air along with his damage output make his placing sort of make sense though.

Just like Suli said, why is Lloyd so low, and Sheik so high? And Zelda too? Oh yeah, and I think BBM is a bit too high. #GetMadJoey

Zelda seems criminally low for a character that has almost no bad matchups save swordsmen.

Why do you think he's too high? I think he could be low A tier material.

I wonder why sheik is so high

Oh man, I have a lot of things to say about this one lmao. But I'll only state a few:
-Zelda is way too low. She has some of the best killpower in the game and wins almost every non-swordsman MU. What she lacks in neutral is made up with her easy-to-pull-off punish game. She's also been getting good results in tourneys as well, so putting her at B is ridiculous.

-Link in B-? Link has a good combo game, powerful kill moves, vast amounts of annoying projectiles, and disjoints. He might not be the greatest swordsman, but he definitely has the tools to be relevant in today's metagame. B- is much too low.

-Lloyd at 7th .-.? C'mon now. Its been apparent Lloyd is one of the best characters in the game for a while now. Incredible combo game, disjointed range, super hard to punish...He's Bottom S-tier at the lowest.

-Goku should be higher. If you've seen Proto, you'd agree. Really all I got to say.

Kinda tuff to use, bad recovery, easy to combo, and he has a hard time getting back on stage... I only think this because I've never ever fought a decent BBM before. So that means I've never fought Huey, or Joey....

wat
who the f*** uses that as basis of deciding tier lists
thats like making fox mid tier in melee because he's hard

so when's explanation lol

Oh yah, and BBM doesn't get tournament results, and barely any people use him.