[ [url=http://i1128.photobucket.com/albums/m487/Jdj016/WinIdle11_zpsbe5c2df2.gif]Image ][/url]

WIP animation for Win's Idle. I don't want just a regular breathing idle, but it's all I could come up with so far. How does it look?

Another question, would it be okay to make a development thread for the sprites in my game only while this thread would be for my misc stuff?

I have a hard time understanding what this means, but I can't honestly say that I see any improvement. Anatomy is still problematic and volumes are still poorly defined. You really need to study human anatomy more, because I think your sprites clearly show that your grasp of anatomy is lacking. Looking at Win's "base", he seems to have no pelvis, his knee is completely soft and round, and he has a Y shaped line going through the middle of his left bicep. The animation creayes even more issues with the shoulder/chest expanding, and the mysterious bicep line squiggling around. I'm sorry if this feedback isn't very helpful, I would be happy to provide a paintover to illustrate better but I won't have access to my computer until next week.

On another note, I still think your method of finalizing outlines before filling in the blanks with colour is not the most productive. Yes I know this is a popular method, and it isn't "wrong", but I think it does require a degree of three dimensional visualisation that you don't really have at this point. It is in many ways more sensible to start by blocking out the major shapes and shadows before going into the smaller details. I would say that understanding 3d shapes and how those shapes are represented in 2d is your biggest weakness, and by concentrating on outlines and leaving shading to be thrown together in the end, you are avoiding the issue instead of trying to improve on it.