On the topic of Geno again, could Square Enix be considered a second party to Nintendo? My guess is no, which would technically make Geno a third party character since SE owns him. Im also guessing that the fans that want Geno are also not the same fans that argue about having third party characters in a game thats supposed to feature Nintendo's all stars.

Or maybe not, thats just me thinking...

before brawl came out? so you played melee with that airdodge, having literally no other alternative to compare it to other than 64's complete lack of any kind of airdodge, and didn't enjoy the game at all because of it?
making mewtwo fight mario or link fight pikachu with kraid behind you f*** around with the stage wasn't fun at all because of the airdodge. sure pal

Yes, stop acting like its impossible to dislike a game before its sequel comes out.

did you like smash 64

Yes I did.

why did you stick with the series then?

Because Brawl was and still is fun to play to me.

Dont get me wrong, there were things I liked about Melee, and I dont think its a bad game by any means, its just my least favorite of the series.

you said it wasn't fun though

Oh, then let me clear it up, I was talking about Melee not being fun for me.

i know
did you think it was a good game or did you think it wasn't fun because if a game isn't fun then it isn't a good game

Well i tend not to think of it that way, I think of it as, a good game but it has some things i disagree with. So i do think its a good game. Its just that those things I disagree with, take away from the fun of the game for me.

what didn't you like about it?

he already explained that the airdodge (somehow) ruined his enjoyment of the game

Mainly the airdodge putting you into a helpless state, and the speed of the game being too fast for my tastes. It seemed like a huge jump from the first game, even though thats most likely not the case. Either way, i couldnt get used to the pace of the game. It didnt help that the only people i could play with all knew the wavedash technique and abuse it to no end. Something that is not physically possible for me to learn, as my fingers arent fast enough.

One other problem thats a minor issue i have, Brawl also suffers from this unfortunately, I dont like the fact of having to play the 1 player modes as many times as there are characters to get everything. Its a minor issue i brought up before, and i dont think its worth discussing again but yeah.

I dare to say nobody actually cared about those problems before Brawl.

And your point about airdodging being that way is kind of invalid if we remember the first game had no airdodge at all.