I think its a rookie mistake while he is not a new player i can see why he would think it would be a good idea.

What is it you see, then?

Pach has replaced Terra

Hey

Give me a moment to read through the game and I'll have some reads up in a bit

Fair enough. Now I'd like everyone's assessment on the situation please.

So instead of complaining about a lack of reads, why don't we actually comment on the ones already established?

Alright I got some reads.

Brik - Strong town intent, made some very good arguments to help move the town forward. Town
Dephius - Play has been mostly passive. He was pressured by Brik a bit. Hasn't been too active since although I do praise him for trying to get people to produce content since everyone apparently went AWOL. Null-Town
Dr. Geno - Inactive D1, extremely productive D2. Not sure what to think of his whole being inactive on purpose scandal. Null
Franziska - Posts have been helpful. Seems like he wants to move the town forward. Town
Genis - Some silliness with setup speculation in the beginning and RQS. Hasn't done much since. Null-Scum
KA - Not sure what he was thinking using his ability on the very first night of the game. There are much better situations where he could've used that in. Maybe it's a rookie mistake but I'm not ruling him out as scum completely. Null
Kyuubit - Pops in here and there to say something although he seems to want to help. Null-Town
Nixter - Gets town points for trying to help despite his "trap" not working. Null-Town
Champ - My biggest suspect at the moment. All he's done is mimic what others have said and tell others to produce content when he isn't doing so himself. Scum
Thomas - Helped with setup speculation which wasn't necessary at all. That's all there is to go off of honestly. Null

Pachino, would you mind explaining why Genis is leaning scum in your analysis, please?

Sure

The main reason is because he started the whole setup speculation nonsense which I feel was an attempt to look like he was contributing when he wasn't really helping the town much at all

It also arouses my suspicions that his activity steadily declined as soon as he was called out for speculating the setup

Nothing concrete but it does arouse a little suspicion from me

Valid points. Genis has been rather inactive.


Genis, on which side of the spectrum would you place each player if null were not an option?

I feel like you guys didn't see the V/LA, like, a couple days ago. Just got back from Finals and crap, so.

Uhm, no. I did contribute into it (since that's basically how I've been playing mafia as Brik pointed out Day 1, but I didn't "start" it. In fact, iirc, Deph did. Though, it's my fault that it's how I try to contribute while knowing absolutely nothing, so I see why people wouldn't like it.

And Brik, here's my list without the Nulls, I suppose. Not adding any explanations for now since I'm tired.

Franziska von Karma – Town.

Terra Pachino - Mafia.

Dephius – Town.

Nixter – Town.

Brik – Town.

Champ – Mafia.

Thomas – Town.

Dr. Geno – Town.

Kyuubit – Town.

King Arthur – Town.

Since I'm probably going to be bombarded with questions about this, just ask them tomorrow. Oh yeah, I didn't use my ability last night, if that helps too.

Champ, did you use your power last night?

Game don't die please.

how about you explain your reads?

Crap ok. Expect them tomorrow if not today.