You noted it, and asked him about it, but really when you could be voting someone that has this implied knowledge for no explained reason, you're lynching me for something stupid, a mistake anyone could've made. I read the rules, but they changed a lot, and had a whole bunch of gimmicks at the start. Excuse me if I skimmed some bits.
Nothing you say or do is going to change how scummy it is for you to ignore other issues and focus on this one tiny thing, pushing for an unbacked lynch like this.

That explains a LOT of things.

It would explain a lot if someone had gotten a guilty on him. It's like he's using this role now so that when he gets investigated and shown up as guilty, he'll have an excuse.
He's just preparing in advance. At first I thought he might've been a crew member who was just FoSing me, but the way he's acting towards me when I know that I'm townie... From my point of view, you have to understand why I think he's mafia.
Vote: Nooq

*Tries to Stay Calm*

I said that if even if they had a poisoner, they didn't use it on night one because two people died.
Why would I suspect they had a poisoner in the first place? Because two people died tonight as well.
Why is this a problem? Because there was an "error in the system".
So inherently, this tells us two things. One, the killing role is dead, and two, the Mafia have a special role of some sort.

See, it's not uncanny at all. It's just pure logic.

It does seem odd that of all the conclusions we could draw from two deaths N1, you chose the oddly specific and out of the way "If they happened to have a poisoner they didn't use it.".

Ugh. That was the best way I could think of saying it. I have no idea if they have a poisoner! How should I?
I just... oh, nevermind. I've said it a bajillion times now, if you still don't believe me, then I don't know what to say.

yeah uh guys personally I don't think either Tid or [:] are any more scummy than anyone else

(except for nooq, I find his pushing for a Tidlynch is rather strange. I think I'll just FoS him here now)

(actually you know what, unvote Vote: nooq)

(pressurepressurepressurepressure)

How quaint so a no lynch is out of question. Out of all of you Tid may seem scummy but does seem to not be covering anything. Kill me the new one is just a waste of all your votes for I do not like to force a stupid death on anyone. so my vote is on hold

Come on, you're not even trying now. I've made it pretty clear that you're scum, when people start agreeing with me you can't just decide they're omgmafiabuddies.
I've been suspicious of Panda for a while now, and I'm calling [:] out as maf. If I were mafia, I wouldn't be stupid enough to bus both of my teammates.

You didn't just vote me though. You voted me with little to no reason, and are continuing to do so despite the fact that others are coming off far scummier than I.
I'm hunting to, I'm just not posting every single thing I think of and responding to every post. I'm storing up my thoughts and theories and posting them when it's a good time to. For example, earlier today I posted detailing why I thought [:] was mafia, which is becoming more and more likely by the moment, and why I merely suspected Panda. Now, with you pushing my lynch so hard without a good reason, acting as if it's incredibly obvious how mafia-sided I am, it's quite clear from my point of view that this is either mafia behavior or stupid behavior. And you aren't stupid.
Inactivity isn't scumtell, but active lurking is, which is why I'm suspecting Panda. Just because I've suspected someone with good reasons doesn't mean "omg he's mafia how else would he know panda is guilty"
You attempting to get me lynched without a good reason does however, tend to mean "omg he's mafia why else would he be pushing so hard for this."
You say I'm bussing [:] and Panda. But by doing that you're obviously saying they're both mafia, and from my point of view, knowing that I'm townsided, I could easily say you're just bussing them.

Look this is just going to go around in circles. I'm fairly certain you're mafia.
We both think [:] is mafia, whether you're bussing or not I don't care. Neither of us are going to convince the rest of the town, so us crossing votes is counterproductive. Why don't we just
Vote: [:]

Fine. I suggest nooq tells all of his thoughts about why Tid is a pirate. My FOS is War Panda, but I think [:] might be a pirate as well.
Vote: [:]

Lol, wait till War Panda bandwagons.

If you are who you say you are, Miller, I can understand why you don't care about getting lynched so much, I seriously can. So if that's why you don't care about appearing scummy then sure, but when you do appear scummy, you're certainly not going to make anyone want to lynch who you want to. It's hard to tell with no-one else posting, but as far as I can see, neither of us have convinced the town one way or the other, so I don't think either of us are getting lynched today.

And with inactive players, days are becoming longer. Most of Day 3 were you guys arguing who's scum and who's not.

One thing for sure, no no-lynchs today. I'll investigate War Panda tonight.

Alright. Should go without saying that tonight the protective role goes on JiP.

Agreed.