I guess that's just a mod choice then, most games I know of only give investigative roles notification that their powers went though.

I'll have it tomorrow, k?

A reads list from everybody would be nice.

1. TheOneWhoKnocks : Slightly inclined towards scum. He looks like looking for any chance to lynch. However, it's just a hunch, and not really a solid read.
4. CXCIV : Obvscum lynch pls
5. Mr. Shoop (Weather Report) Died Night 1 and revived Day 3 : Confirmed town, yay!
7. Deciton_Reven : Null. Can't find reasons to put him on either alignment.
8. 135 (Josuke Higashikata) Lynched Day 1 and revived Day 2 : More confirmed towns, yay!
9. Brikanorak : Where you at, Brik? I miss my smart, pressing Brik from the old days. Null.
10. RG4L | Champ : has had two days to get acquainted to the game, but still hasn't done anything besides repeating other players. Scum.
12. King Arthur : Interesting claim, but not really good post game. Null, leaning town.
13. DJ Wizard Cop : I'm not fully sold at you, but Town seems to make most sense for your alignment.
14. Thomas Terminator : Town... or so it seems.

I guess you missed the part where I've been confirmed town for a good while now?

@194: I find your lack of conviction behind your reads disturbing. It makes them sound made up.

Your reads do not line up with your actions.
Your only conclusive read is on Champ, and yet I have seen you put absolutely no pressure on him nor try to validate your read by asking him questions and forcing him to produce original content.

How do you get a scum read on TOWK if Deph confirmed Joseph to be in the game and TOWK is uncounterclaimed?

How do you get a null read on Brik if he claimed not-town?

What do you mean by "Town makes the most sense for your alignment"?

What is the reasoning behind your Thomas read?

I know for a fact that you find information from roles to be inferior to information from the game thread.
If Arthur has a good claim but bad post game, how do you get a town read on him?

reds:

TOWK: I'm probably pulling another Smash Mafia here and confirming him as town because I can't see how he can be scum, but my role says he's in the game. He has to be town.

194: Contrived arguments from Day 1, stalling more than helping, inconsistent actions/reads. Everything points to a Mafia, but my gut keeps telling me you're town and I'm going to regret voting for you. Gah. I have to go with logic though so scum.

Deciton_Reven: Has been helping a lot more since Day 3. Hard to tell but leaning town for the moment.

Brik: Not town. I think lynching him today is a good idea since it's a vote against us gone, which matters a lot since we're probably going to have to go to lylo at some point. With Vaneloppe and Geno gone, we can hope for only 1 kill tonight and a revive from Thomas. We'll have to see.

Champ: He's a new player. His player slot has done very little, I think a reads list from him would help solidify my read of him.

King Arthur: I feel town intent behind his posts. If he's scum then he's gotten a lot better.

DJWizardCop: I think I'm more or less confirmed town, since I knew about TOWK's power increase.

Thomas: I'd really appreciate it if he scum hunted more actively. Town because he's un CC'd reviver.

194/Brik
Champ
Arthur
Deciton
Me, DJ, Thomas, 135, Shoop

^the order of lynching I'm cool with
I just realized half our players are conf town thats awesome

Going to skip certain "confirmed" because lol


194: His Day 1/ 2 posts make me think he's Town. But as others have poianted out, his new reads though. Keeping an eye on him.

Deciton_Reven: I was wary of him from the beginning, due to advice from Terra. I've noticed he doesn't really take a front seat or anything like that, and plays rather passively and seems to avoid attention. And finally, that claim. Why would he, when there is no pressure on him, and while he can remain anonymous, be so eager to claim Doctor? I'm thinking that he's actually Mafia trying to lure out the Doctor, who would otherwise be protecting Thomas.

Brik: Is pretty much not Town lol

Champ: Hasn't really said much lol

King Arthur: I feel town intent behind his posts. If he's scum then he's gotten a lot better.

DJWizardCop: Nice Town reads from posts.

EDIT: Forgot to do KA and accidentally posted the reads from the "template" I was using lol

King Arthur: Seems to jump in to either vote or to push a Lynch, otherwise pretty passive. Got my eyes on him.

Out of the remaining non-confirmed players I gave reads on, I think it's safe to say there is at least one person who has claimed, but is not Town, assuming a minimum of 3 non-Town players left. Excluding Brik.

@TOWK: if you could put some reasoning for your ordering that would be helpful.

194 has been playing oddly, I don't believe his claim makes total sense, as you said his reads don't match his play and actions, jailkeeper is an easy thing to claim as a Mafia. He has a scum read on me despite me being confirmed town. But Brik is confirmed not town, and I'm suspicious of him because we already have a dead third party, so if not 194, he's the safest lynch.

Champ hasn't really done anything at all aside from occasionally coming in and agreeing with whatever's going on. This could be noon play but he's done it consistently all game even after we've pointed it out. I'd like his claim and reads list.

Arthur isn't particularly a scum read to me, but of him and Deciton I'm more inclined to believe Deciton's claim of doctor because with all this killing role nonsense it would balance it out (although doctor is also a pretty easy thing to fake as scum).

The bottom five are all confirmed.

I have been taking some scumhunting notes during the little bit of time that I have on the computer. I am sorry for the inactivity on my behalf due to an music festival that I'm getting ready for.

Reads coming soon to a topic near you

Like I said before, I was trying to confirm or deny one or the other as town. In hindsight, yes, it was a stupid strategy.

Also, updating my reads list, updates in bold:

Because of "good attempt to try and make it seem like I'm one of your scum buddies"